Growth Mindset: A teacher's guide

What is a Growth Mindset?

The concept of a growth mindset is a transformative idea that has found its way into educational settings around the world. It is a belief that intellectual abilities are not just innate talents but can be developed through dedication, hard work, and the right strategies. This contrasts with a false growth mindset, where individuals may pay lip service to the idea of growth but still cling to the belief in natural talent.

A growth mindset culture in the classroom emphasises the remarkable ability of the human brain to adapt and grow. It recognises that brain functions and mechanisms can change, and that everyone can develop their intellectual abilities to higher levels. This perspective plays a vital role in motivation, encouraging students to set realistic goals and persevere in their learning journey.

For example, a teacher developing a growth mindset might praise effort rather than innate ability, highlighting the strategies a student used to overcome a challenge. This approach can lead to a more resilient and adaptive learningenvironment.

According to D. Yeager et al., 2019, a short online growth mindset intervention improved grades among lower-achieving students and increased overall enrolment in advanced mathematics courses in a nationally representative sample of students in secondary education in the United States. This illustrates the tangible impact of developing a growth mindset.

An expert in the field, Carol Dweck, emphasises the importance of growth mindset, stating, "In a growth mindset, challenges are exciting rather than threatening. So rather than thinking, oh, I'm going to reveal my weaknesses, you say, wow, here's a chance to grow."

A relevant statistic that underscores the importance of growth mindset is the overall effect size across studies, which was found to be 0.17, suggesting that intellectual humility boosts the pursuit of mastery Tenelle Porter et al., 2020.

the growth mindset is not just a trendy educational term but a foundational concept that can transform the way students perceive their abilities and approach learning.

• Emphasizes the Development of Abilities: Growth-minded people believe that intellectual abilities can be developed, not just innate.
• Role in Motivation: Encourages setting realistic goals and perseverance, playing a vital role in motivation.
• Supported by Research: Studies in the Journal of Educational Psychologyand Journal of Experimental Social Psychology have shown the positive effects of a growth mindset on learning outcomes.

‍

‍

What is the Difference Between Fixed and Growth Mindset?

A fixed mindset believes that intellectual abilities are innate talents that cannot be changed, while a growth mindset views these abilities as developable through dedication, hard work, and effective strategies. Growth mindset recognises the brain's remarkable ability to adapt and grow, encouraging students to persevere through challenges. This contrast fundamentally affects how students approach learning, with growth mindset leading to greater resilience and motivation in the classroom.

Carol Dweck's groundbreaking work on the dichotomy between fixed and growth mindsets provides a profound insight into human motivation and learning. This dichotomy is not a mere black-and-white classification but a complex spectrum that reveals how individuals perceive their intellectual abilities.

In the field of a fixed mindset, individuals are often preoccupied with how others perceive their intelligence. They believe that their intellectual abilities are static, and failure is a direct reflection of their innate limitations. This mindset leads to a fear of challenges and a reluctance to appear unintelligent. For example, a student with a fixed mindset might avoid taking advanced courses for fear that struggling in them would reveal a lack of natural talent.

On the other hand, those with a growth mindset embrace challenges and see them as opportunities to learn and grow. They believe that intelligence can be developed through effort, strategy, and perseverance. According to Dweck, "No matter what your ability is, effort is what ignites that ability and turns it into accomplishment." This mindset creates resilience and a willingness to tackle difficult problems.

The complexity of Dweck's theory lies in the nuanced understanding that mindsets are not static. They can vary across different domains and even fluctuate within a single domain. A person might exhibit a growth mindset in sports but a fixed mindset in academics. Furthermore, a strong growth mindset in a particular subject like math can momentarily shift towards a fixed mindset when faced with an exceptionally challenging problem.

A study conducted by Dweck revealed that a growth mindset intervention improved grades among lower-achieving students, with an overall effect size of 0.1, underscoring the tangible impact of this mindset on academic achievement.

The implications for educators are profound. Rather than merely praising success, teachers should focus on recognising and encouraging effort, resilience, and the pursuit of challenges. This approach reinforces the powerful idea that success is not about inherent abilities but about continuous growth through deliberate practice.

Key Insights:

• ong id="">Mindset Spectrum: Mindsets can vary across different domains and even fluctuate within a single domain.
• Effort Over Outcome: Recognising and encouraging effort, resilience, and the pursuit of challenges.

‍

How to Develop a Growth Mindset in the Classroom

Creating a classroom culture that creates a growth mindset requires a multifaceted approach that goes beyond simply telling students they can achieve anything. It involves a deliberate and consistent effort to reshape how students perceive their abilities and approach learning. Here are several practical strategies that teachers can implement:

1. Promote Effort and Strategy: Instead of praising students for being "smart," focus on the effort they put into their work and the strategies they used to solve problems. For example, you could say, "I noticed how you persisted with that challenging problem and tried several different approaches until you found one that worked."
2. Reframe Mistakes as Learning Opportunities: Mistakes are inevitable, and they can be powerful learning experiences if framed correctly. Encourage students to see mistakes as opportunities for growth. Create a classroom environment where students feel safe taking risks and making mistakes.
3. Teach About the Brain's Capacity for Growth: Educate students about neuroplasticity, the brain's ability to reorganise itself by forming new neural connections throughout life. When students understand that their brains can grow and adapt, they are more likely to embrace challenges and persevere through difficulties.
4. Encourage a Growth Mindset Language: Use language that promotes a growth mindset. For example, instead of saying "I can't do this," encourage students to say "I can't do this yet." This simple change in language can have a profound impact on their attitude and motivation.
5. Provide Opportunities for Reflection: Encourage students to reflect on their learning experiences and identify areas where they have grown. This can be done through journaling, self-assessments, or class discussions.
6. Model a Growth Mindset Yourself: As a teacher, model a growth mindset yourself. Share your own struggles and challenges with your students, and demonstrate how you learn from your mistakes.

By consistently implementing these strategies, teachers can create a classroom culture that creates a growth mindset and helps students to reach their full potential.

‍

Practical Exercises

Here are some exercises that can be implemented directly in the classroom:

1. "My Mistake Taught Me.." Activity: Have pupils write about a mistake they made, and then write about what they learned from that mistake. Share some of your own examples.
2. Growth Mindset Journaling: Dedicate 5 minutes at the end of each week for pupils to write about a time they overcame a challenge in the past week, focusing on effort and strategies used.
3. "Praise Effort, Not Talent" Roleplay: Split the class into pairs. Have one pupil offer a statement of accomplishment. The other pupil must respond with growth-mindset-oriented praise.

‍

Conclusion

The growth mindset is more than just a buzzword; it's a fundamental shift in perspective that can transform the way students approach learning. By embracing challenges, viewing failures as opportunities, and focusing on effort and strategy, students can unlock their full potential and achieve remarkable things.

As educators, we have a responsibility to cultivate a growth mindset in our classrooms. By creating a supportive and encouraging learning environment, providing opportunities for reflection, and modelling a growth mindset ourselves, we can helps students to become lifelong learners who are not afraid to take risks and pursue their goals with passion and determination. The journey of developing a growth mindset is ongoing, but the rewards are immeasurable.

‍

Fixed Mindset vs Growth Mindset: Key Characteristics

Situation	Fixed Mindset Response	Growth Mindset Response
Facing Challenges	Avoids challenges, fears looking incompetent	Embraces challenges as opportunities to grow
When Struggling	"I'm not smart enough for this"	"I haven't mastered this yet"
Effort Belief	Effort is pointless if you lack talent	Effort is the path to mastery
Response to Feedback	Takes criticism personally, becomes defensive	Values feedback as information for improvement
Others' Success	Feels threatened by peers' achievements	Finds inspiration and lessons in others' success
After Failure	Gives up, labels self as failure	Analyses what went wrong, tries new strategies
Intelligence Belief	Intelligence is fixed at birth	Intelligence can be developed through effort

‍

Based on Carol Dweck's research at Stanford University. Students can shift between mindsets depending on context - the goal is developing growth-oriented thinking habits.

‍

20 Growth Mindset Activities for the Classroom

These evidence-based growth mindset activities help students develop resilience, embrace challenges, and understand that intelligence develops through effort. Implement these activities regularly to build a classroom culture that celebrates learning from mistakes.

1. The Power of Yet: When students say "I can't do this," add "yet" to their statement. Create "Yet" posters and encourage students to reframe negative self-talk by adding this powerful word that acknowledges growth potential.
2. Famous Failures Gallery Walk: Create displays showing how successful people failed before achieving greatness - Einstein's late speech development, J.K. Rowling's rejections, Michael Jordan's high school cut. Discuss how setbacks preceded success.
3. Mistake of the Week Celebrations: Dedicate time each week to share productive mistakes that led to learning. Model this by sharing your own teaching mistakes and what you learned. Normalise errors as essential to the learning process.
4. Brain Neuroplasticity Lessons: Teach students explicitly that their brains grow new neural connections when they struggle with challenging tasks. Use videos and images showing how neurons connect through practice and effort.
5. Effort Praise Reframing: Shift from praising intelligence ("You're so smart!") to praising process ("Your strategy of checking your work really paid off"). Focus feedback on effort, strategies, and improvement rather than ability.
6. Challenge by Choice Tasks: Offer tiered difficulty levels and encourage students to select appropriately challenging work. Celebrate when students choose harder options, emphasising that struggle indicates brain growth.
7. Growth Mindset Journals: Have students maintain reflection journals where they record challenges faced, strategies attempted, and lessons learned. Prompt entries with questions like "What mistake taught you something this week?"
8. The Learning Pit Visualisation: Introduce James Nottingham's Learning Pit concept showing that confusion and struggle are normal parts of deep learning. Help students identify where they are in the pit and strategies for climbing out.
9. Peer Feedback Protocols: Teach students to give growth-oriented feedback focusing on specific improvements rather than judgements. Use sentence stems like "One thing that could strengthen this is..." and "I notice you tried..."
10. Goal Setting with Process Focus: Help students set process goals (strategies and effort) alongside outcome goals (grades and scores). Review both types regularly, emphasising that process goals are within students' control.
11. Fixed Mindset Trigger Tracking: Have students identify situations that trigger fixed mindset thoughts ("I'll never understand this"). Develop personal "if-then" plans for responding with growth-oriented self-talk.
12. Role Model Research Projects: Assign research on how experts in different fields developed their abilities through practice. Students discover that talent is developed, not innate, across domains from sports to science to art.
13. Effort Rubrics: Create rubrics that assess effort and strategy use alongside content mastery. Include criteria like "took on challenges," "persisted when struggling," and "tried multiple approaches."
14. Classroom Language Audit: Work with students to identify fixed mindset language in the classroom and create growth mindset alternatives. Display these translations visibly as reminders for everyone.
15. Before and After Portfolios: Collect early work samples and compare with later pieces. The visible improvement demonstrates that abilities develop through practice, providing concrete growth mindset evidence.
16. Struggle Stories Sharing Circle: Create regular opportunities for students to share stories of overcoming challenges. Focus on the process of working through difficulty rather than the eventual success.
17. Growth Mindset Book Studies: Use picture books or novels featuring characters who develop through effort. Discuss how characters' mindsets affect their choices and outcomes. Recommend: "The Girl Who Never Made Mistakes," "Beautiful Oops!"
18. Expert Visitor Interviews: Invite professionals to share their learning journeys, emphasising the practice and failures behind their expertise. Have students prepare questions about how visitors developed their skills.
19. Mindset Reflection Exit Tickets: End lessons with brief reflections: "What challenged you today? What strategy will you try next time? What did your brain learn from struggling?" Track responses over time.
20. Growth Mindset Affirmation Cards: Create personal affirmation cards students can reference during challenging moments. Include statements like "Mistakes help my brain grow," "Effort is my superpower," and "I'm not there yet, but I'm getting closer."

Developing a growth mindset culture requires consistent reinforcement over time. Start with three or four activities, embed them into classroom routines, then gradually expand. Remember that teachers must genuinely model growth mindset thinking - students quickly detect authenticity.

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

‍

What is a growth mindset in education?

A growth mindset is the belief that intellectual abilities can be developed through dedication, hard work, and effective strategies. This contrasts with a fixed mindset, where abilities are seen as unchangeable traits. In education, it recognises the brain's ability to adapt and grow, encouraging students to view challenges as opportunities to learn rather than threats to their self-image.

‍

How do I implement growth mindset strategies in my classroom?

Start by praising effort and strategy rather than telling pupils they are 'smart' or naturally talented. Encourage students to view mistakes as learning opportunities and use specific language that highlights the process of improvement. Create a classroom culture where challenges are welcomed and struggling is normalised as part of the learning process.

‍

What are the benefits of teaching with a growth mindset approach?

Research shows that growth mindset interventions can improve grades among lower-achieving students and increase enrolmen t in advanced courses. Students develop greater resilience when facing setbacks and are more willing to tackle difficult problems. The approach particularly benefits struggling learners and can help close achievement gaps in subjects like mathematics.

‍

What are common mistakes teachers make when using growth mindset?

Many teachers fall into the trap of a 'false growth mindset', where they use growth mindset language but still believe in natural talent. Another common mistake is praising effort alone without acknowledging effective strategies or progress made. Teachers may also forget that students can have different mindsets across different subjects, requiring tailored approaches for each area of learning.

‍

How do I know if growth mindset is working in my classroom?

Look for students who embrace challenges rather than avoiding them, and who view setbacks as learning opportunities rather than failures. You should notice increased perseverance when tasks become difficult and students asking for help or seeking new strategies. Monitor whether pupils are focusing on their learning process rather than just comparing themselves to others.

‍

Why do students have different mindsets in different subjects?

Students often switch between fixed and growth mindsets depending on the subject because mindset is not a fixed personality trait. A pupil might have a growth mindset in art but a fixed mindset in mathematics, often influenced by past experiences, feedback received, and cultural beliefs about different subjects. This is why teachers need to address mindset development across all curriculum areas rather than assuming it transfers automatically.

‍

Further Reading

• Dweck, C. S. (2006). *Mindset: The new psychology of success*. Random House.
• Yeager, D. S., Romero, C., Paunesku, D., Hulleman, C. S., Schneider, B., Hinojosa, C., .. & Dweck, C. S. (2016). Using design thinking to improve psychological interventions: The case of the growth mindset during the transition to high school. *Journal of Educational Psychology, 108*(3), 374-391.
• Blackwell, L. S., Trzesniewski, K. H., & Dweck, C. S. (2007). Implicit theories of intelligence predict achievement across an adolescent transition: A longitudinal study and an intervention. *Child Development, 78*(1), 246-263.
• Moser, J. S., Schroder, H. S., Heeter, C., Moran, T. P., & Lee, Y. H. (2011). Mind your errors: Evidence for a neural mechanism linking growth mindset to adaptive posterror behaviour. *Psychological Science, 22*(12), 1484-1489.