Maths Deep Dive Questions: A Teacher's Guide

‍

What is a maths Ofsted examination?

OFSTED guidance helps leaders consider curriculum aims. These notes, though not for teachers initially, can start talks about what learners should achieve (OFSTED, various dates).

The infamous OFSTED examinations do require a good grasp of both the curriculum intent and cognitive science. There are no doubts that this professional knowledge can only improve conceptual learning and have a profound impact on the quality of teaching. But within a examination-focussed inspection, for some classroom teachers, the challenge of being able to articulate their approach to teaching might prove challenging.

‍

‍

Curriculum overviews help you shape your curriculum vision. This post outlines the mathematics inspection method. OFSTED training documents (Researchers, Dates) can improve your mathematics curriculum.

Even without the English curriculum, these questions help leaders. The maths aide-memoire and Ofsted focus give teachers an idea of inspections. These also show what effective teaching looks like (Ofsted, date unknown).

‍

What is declarative knowledge in maths teaching?

Declarative knowledge in maths refers to the factual information students need to know, such as number facts, mathematical definitions, and formulas. This foundational knowledge must be explicitly taught and regularly rehearsed before students can apply it to solve problems. Teachers build this through direct instruction, worked examples, and systematic practice of key facts.

• Do plans outline the key number facts to be learned, as well as their benchmarks for automaticity?
• How well are mathematical vocabulary and sentence stems developed alongside key facts and methods?
• Are learners equipped with rules and formulae for working with shape, distance, time, angles?
• Do plans ensure that learners are familiarized with principles enabling the conversion of word problems into equations?
• Do learners have a secure grasp of time, fraction and length facts?

‍

How do you develop procedural knowledge in mathematics?

Research by Anderson (1983) shows explicit modelling aids mathematical learning. Break procedures down, ensuring each step is mastered before moving on. Guided practice and fast feedback supports learners (Sweller, 1988). Varied examples help learners apply procedures accurately (Ericsson et al., 1993).

• Do curriculum plans acknowledge the most efficient and accurate methods of calculation that learners will use in their next stage of mathematics education?
• Is there a balance between procedures that rely on derivation and those that train recall?
• Are learners equipped with knowledge of how to lay out calculations systematically and neatly?
• Are all learners given procedural knowledge that enables them to work in the abstract?
• Can learners calculate with speed and accuracy?

Conditional knowledge

• Do plans help learners to familiarise themselves with the conditions where combinations of facts and methods will be useful?
• Do plans ensure that learners obtain automaticity in linked facts and methods, before being expected to deploy them in problem-solving?
• Are problems chosen carefully, so that learners are increasingly confident with seeing past the surface features and of recognising the deep structure of problems?
• Can learners solve problems without resorting to unstructured trial and error approaches?

‍

How do sequences of lessons develop mathematical knowledge?

• Has the content been carefully selected to ensure learners have the building blocks they need for later work?
• Once key facts and methods are learned, do plans allow learners to apply their learning to different contexts?
• Is progression through the curriculum a guarantee for all and not overly influenced by choice?
• Do plans engineer the successful opportunities to connect concepts within and between topic sequences?
• Do plans rule out the acquisition of common misconceptions?
• Are learner errors immediately highlighted and corrected?

‍

Why is memory important for learning mathematics?

(Brown et al., 2014) argue memory is vital for maths, enabling learners to solve problems. Learners need to remember number facts, otherwise working memory gets overloaded. Spaced practice and retrieval activities help learners retain information (Rohrer, 2009; Karpicke, 2012).

• Do plans ensure that consolidation and overlearning of content takes place at frequent intervals?
• Are learners able to refer to work completed and content learned in previous lessons?
• Do plans strike a balance between rehearsal of explanations or proof of understanding and rehearsal of core facts and methods needed to complete exercises and solve problems?
• Do plans prioritise thinking about core content by ensuring that learners know what to do?
• Do plans actively prevent the need for guessing, casting around for clues and unstructured trial and error?
• Can learners recall, rather than derive, facts and formulae, without the use of memory aids?

Early Years

• Do plans close the school entry gap in knowledge of number?
• Do plans allow for learning of key number facts and an efficient and accurate method of counting before learners are expected to solve everyday problems?
• Are learners given key mathematical language?
• Are curriculum plans equitable?

Disciplinary rigour

• Do learners know that proficiency in mathematics requires sustained effort and focus?
• Are learners encouraged to be precise, accurate and systematic in their mathematical endeavours?
• Do plans give learners undisturbed opportunities to hone their effort and focus?

‍



‍

What are the most effective pedagogical approaches for teaching maths?

Explicit maths teaching needs structured practice, going from concrete to abstract. Variation theory, as suggested by researchers like Marton & Pang (2006), shows maths connections. Teachers should assess learners often, addressing errors quickly, as Black & Wiliam (1998) noted. High expectations matter.

Instruction

• Are instructional approaches systematic, with new content introduced in a logical order, building on what learners know?
• Can learners answer questions without needing to guess or cast around for clues?
• Does instruction make sense to learners?
• Are diagrams and physical apparatus helpful?

‍

How should retrieval practice be used in maths assessment?

Retrieval practicein maths should include daily low-stakes quizzing on previously taught content, not just recent topics. Teachers can use starter activities, exit tickets, and homework to regularly test key facts and procedures from across the curriculum. This approach strengthens memory and helps identify gaps in understanding before they become barriers to new learning.

Component parts (facts and methods)

• Are learners regularly tested on their recall of core maths facts?
• Are the prescribed benchmarks for accuracy and speed of recall true indicators of automaticity?
• Do learners know they are improving?
• Do plans incorporate opportunities for assessing learners’ knowledge of core methods such as finding equivalent fractions, converting measurements or using short division outside of requirements to use these methods for problem-solving?

Composite skills (applied facts and methods)

• Are learners prepared for tests of composite skills?
• Are summative tests of this nature kept to a minimum?
• Are learners familiar with the typical language used in these tests?

‍

What makes a strong maths curriculum culture in schools?

Teachers must understand and use the planned maths sequence across years. See "Mastery in maths" for guidance. Leaders should train staff on cognitive science and maths teaching. They need to monitor this with learning walks and book looks. Prioritise deep understanding, not just surface knowledge. Celebrate learners' maths thought processes.

• Is the homework policy equitable and effective, supporting the consolidation of learning and closing knowledge and retention gaps?
• Are adequate resources available?
• Does the calculation policy prioritise learning/use of efficient and accurate methods of calculation for all learners?
• Is the marking policy reasonable and clear?
• Is proficiency in mathematics celebrated?
• Do learners appreciate the ways in which mathematics underpins advances in technology and science?
• Is quiet, focussed scholarship in mathematics promoted?
• Do learners know that creativity, motivation and love of mathematics follow success born of hard work?
• What enrichment activities are offered?

‍

When should schools introduce key mathematical facts and definitions?

Mathematical facts need a planned sequence, building from basics. Ensure learners know prior facts before new content, using concrete-pictorial-abstract methods. Regular factual recall checks show when learners are ready for harder ideas (Bruner, 1966).

Early years

and spatial reasoning; awareness of shape using pattern blocks, linking cubes, and 3D solids; an ability to subitise numbers to 5; a foundational understanding of mathematical language; and the recognition of patterns are the bedrock of mathematical competence in young learners (Nunes & Bryant, 2009; Clements & Sarama, 2009). Such competencies provide a base to which subsequent learning can be effectively grafted (Price, 2009), yet many learners arrive at school lacking these fundamental mathematical skills (Aubrey & Dahl, 2006) and foundational mathematical knowledge (Gifford, 2004). Without these skills, teachers are faced with the unenviable task of addressing these gaps while attempting to teach a prescribed curriculum (Wright et al., 2006). Learners need number bonds to 10 and maths vocabulary (Nunes & Bryant, 2009). Spatial reasoning and shape awareness are also crucial (Clements & Sarama, 2009). Subitising to 5 and pattern recognition form a solid base (Price, 2009). Many learners lack these vital maths skills when starting school (Aubrey & Dahl, 2006; Gifford, 2004). Teachers must fill these gaps while teaching the curriculum (Wright et al., 2006).

Key Stage 1

• Concepts, representations and associated vocabulary:
• Simple fractions
• Basic arithmetic: the numbering system and its symbols, place value, conventions for expressions and equations, counting, addition, subtraction, equal sharing, doubling, balancing simple arithmetic equations, classifying numbers (odd, even, teens), inverse operations, estimation, numerical patterns
• Basic measurement: length; capacity; time; position; relative size, position, direction, motion, quantity
• Currency and coinage
• Basic geometry: 2D and 3D shapes, geometric patterns
• Categorical data
• Maths facts: all number bonds within and between 20; key number bonds within and between 100, all multiplication facts for the 2, 5 and 10 multiplication tables, key ‘fraction facts’ such as ‘half of 6 is 3’, key ‘time facts’ such as the number of minutes in an hour

Lower Key Stage 2

Concepts, representations and associated vocabulary:

• Arithmetic: enhanced knowledge of the code for number (to 1000s) including patterns and associated rules for addition and subtraction of numbers, decimal numbers, place value, negative numbers, associative and distributive laws
• Maths facts: all multiplication facts for the 3, 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12 multiplication tables, decimal equivalents of key fractions
• Equivalent fractions
• Formulae: Units of measurement conversion rules, formulae for perimeter and area
• Roman Numeral system and associated historical facts
• Geometry facts: right angles, acute and obtuse angles, right angles in whole and half turns, symmetry, triangle and quadrilateral classifications; horizontal, perpendicular, parallel and perpendicular lines
• Links between words/phrases in word problems and their corresponding operations in mathematics (e.g. ‘spending’ is associated with ‘subtraction from an amount’)
• The rules for multiplying and dividing by 10, 100 and 1000
• First quadrant grid coordinate principles

Upper Key Stage 2

Concepts, representations and associated vocabulary:

• Enhanced knowledge of the code for number: up to and within 1 000 000, multiples, factors, decimals, prime number facts to 100, composite numbers, indexation for square and cubed numbers
• Properties of linear sequences
• Conversion facts metric to imperial measurements and vice versa
• Key circle, quadrilateral and triangle facts and formulae (e.g. Angles on a straight line sum to 180 degrees)
• Rules and principles governing order of operations

‍

How can teachers ensure deep learning of mathematical procedures?

Research by Baroody et al. (2007) says learners gain deeper knowledge when they grasp why procedures work. Teachers can link methods to maths concepts; learners explain their reasoning (Rittle-Johnson et al., 2001). Varying the problem context aids learners in seeing the maths structure (Star & Seifert, 2006).

Early years

Accurate counting, single-digit addition and subtraction, halving doubling and sharing

Key Stage 1

Efficient and accurate methods:

• Counting up and down in 1s, 2, 5s, 10s and 1/2s; addition; subtraction, equal sharing, division and multiplication
• Reading, writing of the digits/symbols, vocabulary and phrases required for working with simple fractions, arithmetic expressions and equations
• Measuring length, capacity, time and monetary value
• Presentation and layout of calculations
• Using a ruler
• Spotting and making geometric and numerical patterns
• Construction and interpretation of categorical data: pictograms, charts, tables

Lower Key Stage 2

Efficient and accurate methods:

• Counting up and down in multiples of 3, 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 11, 12, 25, 50, 100, 1000, in tenths, in ones through to negative numbers
• Column addition and subtraction
• Mental addition and subtraction using patterns and rules of number
• Short division and multiplication
• Mental multiplication using derived facts
• Fractions: finding unit and non-unit fractions of amounts, common equivalents, addition, subtraction and comparison of fractions with the same denominator
• Measure, compare, add, subtract: lengths, mass, capacity (all units of measurement)
• Read, write and compare roman numerals
• Draw 2D and 3D shapes
• Interpret and present data
• Estimation and rounding
• First quadrant grid construction, plotting and translation of points

Upper Key Stage 2

Efficient and accurate methods

• Scaling, coordinate geometry in all four quadrants
• Division with remainders as fractions, decimals and where rounding is needed
• Fractions: conversion mixed to improper and vice versa, add, subtract and multiply
• Finding percentages of amounts
• Converting units of measurement
• Measurement of length, angles, area, perimeter, volume
• Use of order of operations
• Convert between fractions, decimals and percentages Linear algebra, basic trigonometry Long multiplication and division

‍



‍

What is conditional knowledge in mathematics and why does it matter?

Researchers like Verschaffel et al. (1999) show learners need varied maths problems. Learners build conditional knowledge when they select strategies, not follow rules. Teachers improve this by discussing choices and using mixed practice activities.

Early years

Use combinations of number facts, shape facts, pattern facts, methods of counting, addition and subtraction to

• Play games
• Sing songs
• Answer questions
• Talk about everyday objects
• Solve problems using objects within continuous provision

Key Stage 1

Use combinations of taught and rehearsed facts and methods to:

• Complete written exercises
• Solve missing number problems
• Solve simple word problems involving arithmetic, money, time and fractions
• Solve data and measurement problems

Lower Key Stage 2

Employ a mix of learned and practiced information and methods to:

• Complete written exercises
• Solve missing number, length problems
• Solve word problems involving arithmetic, fractions, data handling, shape, length, mass and capacity

Upper Key Stage 2

Utilise a blend of memorised and prepared tools and techniques for: finishing written tasks

‍

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

What exactly is a maths Ofsted examination and how does it differ from regular inspections?

Ofsted maths inspections focus on the curriculum through teacher conversations. Teachers explain their maths teaching and show they understand curriculum aims. They also demonstrate knowledge of cognitive science principles (Ofsted, 2023) supporting effective learner progress (Brownell, 1945; Bruner, 1960; Sweller, 1988).

‍

How can teachers effectively prepare for examination conversations with Ofsted inspectors?

Teachers, discuss how you build learner knowledge. Give examples of teaching number facts, vocab, and problem-solving. Explain how lessons build maths knowledge systematically. Describe using spaced practice and retrieval activities for long-term memory (Bjork, 1992; Karpicke, 2016; Brown et al., 2014).

‍

What is the Memory Mathematics Framework and how does it transform lesson planning?

The Memory Mathematics Framework uses cognitive science for maths teaching. It helps learners keep mathematical knowledge (Kirschner et al., 2006). Explicitly teach declarative knowledge, then systematically practice procedures (Sweller, 1988). Regular retrieval practice reinforces long term memory (Roediger & Butler, 2011). This prevents working memory overload (Cowan, 2010).

‍

Why do learners struggle with word problems and what teaching approach helps them overcome this?

Learners find word problems hard; they see surface details, not maths. Problem selection should focus on the maths behind the words. Learners need fast recall of facts and methods before tackling problems. Teach systematic equation creation (Hegarty et al., 2023).

‍

How should schools balance the teaching of mathematical facts versus understanding in their curriculum?

Explicit teaching and rehearsal help learners master facts (declarative knowledge). Learners then apply this to problem-solving. Balance derivation with recall, letting learners access abstract maths without fact retrieval struggles (Kirschner, Sweller & Clark, 2006).

‍

What specific questions should curriculum leaders ask to audit their maths provision effectively?

Leaders, check plans for key number facts and automaticity goals. Ensure maths vocabulary grows alongside methods (Hodgen et al., 2018). Confirm learners have rules for shape, time and measurement (Skemp, 1976). Verify lessons prevent misconceptions and provide consolidation chances (Bjork, 1992; Rohrer, 2009).

‍

How can retrieval practice be implemented effectively in mathematics teaching and assessment?

This regular testing solidifies learning. Low stakes quizzes covering older topics are key for retrieval practice. Teachers can use starters, exit tickets or homework (Roediger & Butler, 2011). Regular recall helps find learning gaps before they become a problem (Bjork, 1992; Karpicke & Blunt, 2011).