Subject leadership in Primary Schools

​

‍

What is subject leadership in Primary Schools?

Subject leadership in primary schools plays a critical role in shaping the educational landscape, particularly within the English primary school system. It involves the strategic oversight and development of specific curriculum subjects by designated leaders, usually experienced teachers, who spearhead curriculum design and delivery in their areas of expertise. These leaders are integral in ensuring that the school's curriculum not only aligns with the national curriculum but also meets the diverse learning needs of all students. Subject leaders work in collaboration with the senior leadership team to define curriculum expectations, manage curriculum progression, and enhance the quality of teaching through effective pedagogical content knowledge.

The importance of subject leadership stems from its capacity to influence educational outcomes directly. By possessing deep pedagogical content knowledge, subject leaders can craft a well-planned curriculum that promotes robust learning pathways for students. They are also responsible for the continuous assessment of subjects, utilising both formative and summative assessment activities to inform instructional practices and support curriculum refinement. This targeted focus ensures that teaching is not only effective but also adaptable to the evolving educational demands and challenges within the primary school setting.

Subject leadership contributes significantly to the overall quality of education by emphasising the importance of specialised knowledge and leadership in curriculum development. This is particularly crucial in the primary years, where foundational knowledge and skills are established. Here are three key points that underscore the importance of subject leadership in primary schools:

• Curriculum Design and Progression: Subject leaders ensure the curriculum is dynamic and progressively builds on students' knowledge and skills.
• Enhanced Quality of Teaching: Through expert knowledge and strategic planning, subject leaders help improve the teaching standards across subjects.
• Focused Assessment Practices: Regular and systematic assessments led by subject leaders help in fine-tuning teaching methods and curriculum delivery to improve student learningoutcomes.

‍

‍

‍

‍

What are the opportunities in subject leadership?

• It can give learners the chance to be immersed and initiated into the rich traditions of history, geography, music, and other subjects,
• It can provide the chance for school leaders (Subject specialist of all levels of experience within the school) to contribute to a mutual, collaborative goal and, in turn, develop their expertise for the sake of school improvement.

However, it is wise to note that there is absolutely no assurance that there will be a balance of teachers with the drive and passion for offering quality teaching or those with enough expertise to accomplish it within a staff body of primary school teachers.

This is evident in the Carter Review (DfE Department for Education, a ministerial department responsible.. More, 2015) stated that teachers fresh from college entering the teaching profession might not necessarily have the same knowledge base (due in part to differences in their teacher training and teaching resource). Problems for subject leaders are likely to be encountered by those that may lack the required expertise in a specific curriculum area and have never had an opportunity to develop themselves a step further. It then follows that if there is a lack of knowledge among subject leaders or knowledge organisers in primary school, it might be very tough for the curriculum of that subject to be developed successfully. Therefore, primary school leaders should consider how they will ensure that the curriculum intent is designed effectively to provide for their pupils' needs while also developing t heir staff's subject knowledge and expertise.

‍

How Should Primary Schools Allocate Subject Leadership Roles?

Primary schools should allocate subject leadership roles based on teachers' expertise, experience, and passion for specific curriculum areas. The allocation process involves matching staff strengths with curriculum needs while ensuring equitable distribution of responsibilities across the team. Senior leadership should consider workload balance and provide adequate time for leaders to fulfil their responsibilities effectively.

The first thing to ask ourselves is what can be done about it. First and foremost, to answer the question is to see the subject specialist of the curriculum as a collaborative task, where all the teaching staff is helped to be part of the growth process. A significant difference ought to be made between formal leadership positions and the distribution of leadership within the primary school. Senior leadership (synonymous with traditional leadership) has a significant but indirect effect on student outcomes in schools (Rhodes and Brundrett, 2010).

Class teachers have the most contact with the pupils, and success highly depends on them delivering curriculum expectations. However, senior leaders are integral to the success of their pupils too. The senior leaders may set the strategic vision and craft goals for their staff to deliver high-quality instruction of the intended curriculum, but it is the teacher who provides the curriculum. The teacher makes sense of it pedagogically and inspires students to take up their opportunities. Therefore, they should have the agency to make them their own (Hargreaves and O'Connor, 2018).

Therefore, it is integral that senior leaders distribute their leadership to ensure that all of their teaching staff are being developed to reach their full potential. If the subject leadership wants to ensure that the curriculum is collaboratively developed, as Harris (2004) notes:, The job of those in formal leadership positions should hold the pieces of the organisation together in a productive relationship… distributing leadership equates with maximising the human capacity within the organisation' (p.g.14)

The central premise of this claim is that formal responsibilities or management structures do not bind that leadership; leadership ought to be dispersed, collective, collaborative, and shared. Therefore, primary school teachers should hold discussions with curriculum specialists and be responsible for its development, so everyone can make a meaningful contribution to the intended curriculum.

When the subject leadership role of the curriculum is developed, so everyone can make a meaningful contribution to the intended curriculum.

‍

What Strategies Can Enhance Subject Leadership?

Several strategies can enhance the effectiveness of subject leadership in primary schools. These strategies focus on supporting subject leaders, developing collaboration, and promoting continuous professional development.

• Allocate Time for Subject Leadership: Ensure subject leaders have dedicated time for planning, assessment, and collaboration. Reducing teaching load or providing additional planning days can alleviate pressure.
• Provide Professional Development: Offer subject-specific professional development opportunities, such as courses, workshops, and conferences, to deepen their pedagogical content knowledge.
• creates Collaboration: Encourage subject leaders to collaborate with colleagues, both within and outside the school, to share best practices and effective approaches. This can involve creating subject-specific networks or organising joint planning sessions.
• Regular Feedback and Support: Senior leadership should provide regular feedback and support to subject leaders, acknowledging their contributions and addressing any challenges they face.

By implementing these strategies, primary schools can helps subject leaders to drive curriculum development and enhance the quality of teaching and learning.

‍

Conclusion

Subject leadership is an essential component of a thriving primary school environment. Effective subject leaders contribute to a well-designed, dynamic curriculum that meets the diverse needs of all learners. By helping subject leaders with the necessary time, resources, and support, schools can ensure that curriculum development and delivery are of the highest quality.

‍

Challenges Facing Subject Leaders in Practice

Subject leaders in primary schools encounter numerous obstacles that can significantly impact their effectiveness. One of the most prevalent challenges is time constraints, as many subject leaders are full-time class teachers with limited non-contact time to fulfil their leadership responsibilities. This often results in curriculum planning and monitoring activities being relegated to evenings and weekends, leading to potential burnout and reduced effectiveness.

Budget limitations present another significant hurdle, particularly for subjects beyond English and mathematics. Subject leaders frequently struggle to secure adequate funding for resources, training, and professional development opportunities. This is especially challenging for practical subjects such as design and technology, science, or art, where specialist equipment and materials are essential for effective delivery.

Many primary school subject leaders also face the challenge of limited subject expertise across their teaching colleagues. Unlike secondary schools where teachers typically specialise in specific subjects, primary teachers must deliver across the entire curriculum. This means subject leaders often need to provide extensive support and professional development to colleagues who may lack confidence or knowledge in particular subject areas.

Workload management becomes particularly complex when teachers hold multiple subject leadership roles, which is common in smaller primary schools. Balancing the demands of different subjects whilst maintaining quality standards requires exceptional organisational skills and clear prioritisation strategies.

To address these challenges, successful schools implement structured solutions such as dedicated leadership time, subject-specific professional development programmes, and collaborative networks with other schools. Creating detailed action plans with realistic timescales and establishing clear communication channels with senior leadership helps subject leaders navigate these obstacles more effectively.

‍

Developing Effective Subject Action Plans

Creating comprehensive subject action plans is fundamental to successful subject leadership in primary schools. These strategic documents serve as roadmaps for curriculum development and provide clear direction for both the subject leader and their colleagues. An effective action plan should begin with a thorough subject audit that evaluates current provision, identifies strengths and areas for development, and establishes baseline data for future comparison.

The planning process should incorporate SMART objectives (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) that align with the school's overall development priorities and Ofsted requirements. For example, a mathematics subject leader might establish an objective to "improve Year 4 problem-solving skills by 15% as measured by standardised assessments within one academic year through weekly problem-solving sessions and targeted intervention programmes."

Resource planning forms a crucial component of effective action plans. Subject leaders must identify required materials, training needs, and budgetary requirements well in advance. This includes considering both immediate needs and longer-term strategic investments that will benefit the subject over multiple years.

Successful action plans also incorporate regular monitoring and evaluation cycles with clearly defined success criteria. This might include termly book scrutinies, lesson observations, pupil voice activities, and data analysis sessions. The plan should specify who will be responsible for each monitoring activity and when it will occur throughout the academic year.

Collaboration opportunities should be embedded within the action plan, including peer observations, team teaching arrangements, and professional learning communities. Many successful primary schools establish subject-specific working groups that meet regularly to share best practices and address common challenges. The action plan should also outline communication strategies for keeping all stakeholders informed of progress and developments.

‍

Building Subject Leadership Capacity

Developing robust subject leadership capacity requires a systematic approach to identifying, nurturing, and supporting potential leaders within the school community. Succession planning is essential, particularly in smaller primary schools where subject leadership responsibilities may be concentrated among a few experienced staff members. Schools should actively identify teachers who demonstrate passion and aptitude for specific subjects and provide them with structured development opportunities.

Mentorship programmes prove highly effective in building subject leadership capacity. Pairing experienced subject leaders with emerging leaders creates valuable learning opportunities and ensures knowledge transfer. This relationship should include regular meetings, joint planning sessions, and collaborative monitoring activities that gradually build confidence and expertise.

Professional development opportunities extend beyond formal training courses to include practical leadership experiences. Aspiring subject leaders benefit from leading staff meetings, coordinating special events, or managing small-scale projects that develop their organisational and communication skills. Many successful schools create deputy subject leader roles that provide structured pathways for career progression.

External networking plays a crucial role in capacity building. Subject leaders should be encouraged to participate in local authority subject networks, attend specialist conferences, and engage with subject-specific professional organisations. These connections provide access to current research, effective practices, and peer support that enhances leadership effectiveness.

Schools should also invest in leadership training programmes that develop generic leadership skills alongside subject-specific expertise. This includes training in areas such as performance management, budget management, and strategic planning. Creating opportunities for subject leaders to present to governors or parent groups builds confidence and communication skills that benefit their overall effectiveness.

‍

Measuring Impact and Success

Effective measurement of subject leadership impact requires a comprehensive approach that goes beyond traditional test scores to encompass the broader educational experience. Pupil progress data remains fundamental, but subject leaders should analyse trends across multiple cohorts and consider contextual factors that may influence outcomes. This includes examining progress rates for different groups of learners, identifying gaps in achievement, and tracking long-term trends that indicate curriculum effectiveness.

Qualitative indicators provide valuable insights into subject leadership success. Regular pupil voice activities can reveal student engagement levels, subject enjoyment, and perceived relevance of learning. Subject leaders should conduct structured interviews or surveys that explore pupils' attitudes, confidence levels, and understanding of progression within their subject area.

Teacher confidence and competence represent crucial success metrics that subject leaders must monitor systematically. This involves gathering feedback through professional learning conversations, observing changes in teaching practice, and measuring participation rates in subject-specific training opportunities. Many successful schools use teacher self-evaluation tools that track confidence levels across different aspects of subject delivery.

Curriculum coverage and quality indicators include analysis of long-term planning documents, assessment of resource utilisation, and evaluation of cross-curricular links. Subject leaders should maintain comprehensive records of curriculum delivery that demonstrate breadth, progression, and depth across all year groups.

External validation through Ofsted inspections, local authority reviews, or peer school partnerships provides objective perspectives on subject leadership effectiveness. Subject leaders should actively seek feedback from these sources and use findings to refine their strategic approaches. Successful schools often arrange reciprocal subject review visits with partner institutions that provide valuable external perspectives on provision quality and leadership impact.

Ultimately, the success of subject leadership hinges on a collaborative approach, where all teachers are helped to contribute their expertise and passion to the curriculum. When teachers work together, share best practices, and continuously refine their teaching methods, they create a learning environment that inspires students to achieve their full potential. By embracing distributed leadership and developing a culture of continuous improvement, primary schools can develop the transformative power of subject leadership.

‍

Further Reading

Subject leadership research

Curriculum leadership

Middle leadership in schools

• Bolam, R., McMahon, A., Stoll, L., Thomas, S., & Wallace, M. (2005). *How do leadership, teaching and learning interrelate in effective schools?* National College for School Leadership.
• Harris, A. (2004). Distributed leadership and school improvement: Leading or misleading?. *Educational Management Administration & Leadership, 32*(1), 11-24.
• Leithwood, K., Day, C., Sammons, P., Harris, A., & Hopkins, D. (2006). *Seven strong claims about successful school leadership*. National College for School Leadership.
• Rhodes, C., & Brundrett, M. (2010). *Leadership under pressure*. Routledge.
• Timperley, H., Wilson, A., Barrar, C., & Fung, I. (2007). *Teacher professional learning and development: Best evidence synthesis iteration [BES]*. Ministry of Education.