Beyond Phonics: How the Toe by Toe Manual Transforms Reading Ability

Key Takeaways

• Toe by Toe is a highly structured, multi-sensory reading manual for struggling readers of any age, designed to be delivered in daily 20-minute, one-to-one sessions.
• It focuses on building accurate phonetic decoding by using non-words to prevent guessing and a cumulative, repetitive structure to secure skills in long-term memory.
• The programme is designed to be delivered by any literate person, including teaching assistants, parents, and peer mentors, without requiring specialist training.
• Evidence shows it can produce significant gains in reading accuracy and fluency, but it must be paired with guided oral reading and comprehension activities to be fully effective.
• Its primary limitation in schools is the logistical challenge of timetabling daily one-to-one sessions.

What is the Toe by Toe Reading Manual?

Toe by Toe is a highly structured, cumulative reading intervention programme contained in a single red manual. Developed by Keda Cowling, it was designed specifically to support learners who struggle with reading, including those diagnosed with dyslexia. For over two decades, it has become a staple resource in many UK schools, used by SENCOs, teachers, and teaching assistants to provide targeted support.

‍

The manual is essentially a self-contained toolkit. It requires no specialist training to deliver, only a literate 'coach' and a willing learner. Its core principle is to break reading down into its smallest component parts, individual phonetic sounds, and build them back up, step-by-step. This systematic approach aims to move a learner from struggling to decode single letters to reading fluently with confidence.

Unlike many other resources, Toe by Toe is explicitly designed for a one-to-one coaching relationship. The format consists of carefully sequenced exercises, from single sounds and non-words to full sentences, that the coach and learner work through together.

‍

Who is Toe by Toe For (And Who Is It Not For)?

A common misconception is that Toe by Toe is exclusively for learners with dyslexia. While it is highly effective for this group, its application is much broader. Deciding if it's the right fit requires understanding the specific nature of a learner's reading difficulty.

Toe by Toe is most effective for learners who:

• Guess at words: If a learner sees 'cat' and says 'kitten', or 'house' and says 'home', they are relying on context and initial letters, not decoding. Toe by Toe systematically breaks this habit.
• Struggle with phonetic decoding: Learners who cannot reliably blend sounds to read unfamiliar words will benefit from the manual's structured approach.
• Have a poor reading memory: The repetitive, cumulative nature of the exercises is designed to embed letter-sound correspondences in long-term memory.
• Are of any age: The content is age-neutral, making it suitable for a Year 3 learner, a KS3 learner in secondary school, or even an adult.

Toe by Toe is NOT the right intervention for learners who:

• Can decode but lack comprehension: If a learner can read a page of text accurately but cannot tell you what it was about, their difficulty lies with comprehension, not decoding. They need strategies for vocabulary, background knowledge, and making sense of text, not more phonics.
• Are in the initial stages of learning to read: The programme is an intervention, not a primary phonics curriculum. It is for learners who have already been taught phonics but have not been ableto master the skill.
• Require a multi-sensory approach involving extensive physical movement: While it is multi-sensory in that it involves seeing, saying, and hearing, it is a book-based, table-top activity.

The Core Mechanics: How Toe by Toe Builds Reading Fluency

The success of Toe by Toe lies in its simple but rigid structure. It is designed to remove cognitive overload and build automaticity through a series of carefully controlled exercises.

‍

The One-to-One, 20-Minute Session

The manual is designed for short, frequent sessions, ideally 20 minutes every day. This consistency is more important than the length of any single session. This daily reinforcement is important for learners with poor working memories, as it prevents the "forgetting curve" that can occur between less frequent sessions.

‍

Using Non-Words to Force Decoding

A key feature of the manual is its extensive use of nonsense words (e.g., 'tok', 'mip', 'bim'). This is a deliberate and critical design choice. Real words allow learners to draw on their vocabulary and guess from context. Non-words remove this crutch entirely. To read a nonsense word correctly, the learner has no choice but to apply their phonetic knowledge, sound out the letters, and blend them. This isolates the skill of decoding and makes it impossible to "cheat."

‍

Syllable Division for Longer Words

When learners progress to multi-syllable words, Toe by Toe provides a unique visual scaffold. Words are printed with dots or dashes to guide the learner in breaking them down into manageable chunks (e.g., 'con-tent'). This technique, known as syllable division, reduces the cognitive load of tackling a long, intimidating word and teaches the learner a strategy they can apply to any word they encounter.

‍

The Three-Tick Mastery System

Progress is tracked directly on the page. When a learner reads a word or sound correctly, the coach marks a tick next to it. To be considered 'mastered', a sound or word must be read correctly on three separate, consecutive occasions. A dot is used to mark an incorrect attempt. This simple system provides immediate visual feedback, building a sense of achievement as the page fills with ticks. It also ensures that a skill is truly secure before the learner moves on.

‍

The Cognitive Science: Why the Repetition Works

The methodology of Toe by Toe is grounded in established principles of cognitive science, which explains why it can be so effective for struggling readers.

‍

The core challenge for many struggling readers is a bottleneck in working memory. They expend so much cognitive effort trying to decode individual words that they have no mental capacity left to comprehend the meaning of the sentence. The goal of any effective reading intervention is to make decoding automatic.

Toe by Toe achieves this through systematic overlearning. By repeatedly practising the same sound-symbol relationships in a structured way, the knowledge is transferred from the effortful working memory to the vast long-term memory. This process of automatisation is fundamental to skilled reading (Sweller, 1988).

‍

‍

Research on structured literacy interventions consistently shows positive effects for struggling readers (Nilvius et al., 2020; Bakken et al., 2021). The structured, explicit, and cumulative nature of these programmes reduces the cognitive burden on the learner. By controlling the introduction of new information and ensuring mastery before progression, the manual keeps the learning within the learner's cognitive capacity.

UK-specific reviews have found that one-to-one delivery of programmes like Toe by Toe can have a "useful" impact, producing measurable gains in both reading accuracy and comprehension (Lavan & Talcott, 2020). However, the largest gains are seen in word identification and fluency, with less impact on comprehension when the intervention is used in isolation (O’Rourke et al., 2021). This underscores the need to see it as one part of a broader literacy strategy.

‍

Implementing Toe by Toe: A Step-by-Step Guide for Schools

Successful implementation requires careful planning and a commitment to the programme's methodology. The biggest barrier is often logistical, not pedagogical.

‍

Step 1: Identifying the Right Learners

Use simple diagnostic assessments to identify learners whose primary difficulty is with phonetic decoding. Look for a significant gap between their listening comprehension (what they understand when read to) and their independent reading level. These are the learners most likely to benefit.

‍

Step 2: Resourcing and Timetabling the Intervention

This is the most challenging aspect. Finding a daily 20-minute one-to-one slot for multiple learners is a significant resource commitment.

• Who can be the coach? The programme is designed to be delivered by any literate adult. Teaching assistants are often ideal, but schools have also had success with trained parent volunteers and even older peer mentors. The key is consistency in the coach-learner pairing.
• When to run sessions? Many schools utilise registration time, assembly time, or extract learners from non-core subjects on a rotating basis. Some run sessions during lunchtime or after school, though this can be less effective if the learner is tired.

Step 3: A Typical 20-Minute Session in Action

A Year 7 learner, Leo, sits with his TA in a quiet corner of the library.

• The TA says: "Right Leo, let's start where we left off yesterday." She opens the red manual to a page of non-words. "Remember, these are silly words. Sound it out in your head first, then say the whole word."
• Leo does: He looks at the word 'mip'. He silently mouths the sounds 'm-i-p' and then says "mip" aloud. The TA marks a tick next to the word. He moves to the next word, 'tig', but says 'tag'. The TA gently corrects him, "Close, try that middle sound again," and marks a dot for the incorrect attempt. They will come back to this word tomorrow.
• The goal: This forces Leo to use his phonic knowledge, eliminating his usual habit of guessing. The instant feedback and correction prevent him from practising errors.

Step 4: Beyond the Manual: Connecting Decoding to Comprehension

This is a critical, non-negotiable step. Using Toe by Toe alone risks creating learners who can decode words but do not read for meaning, a phenomenon sometimes called "barking at print".

Immediately after the 20-minute Toe by Toe session, the coach should spend 5-10 minutes in a guided oral reading activity.

• The Coach: Takes a book that is at the learner's instructional level (around 90-95% accuracy). The coach reads a sentence aloud with fluency and expression.
• The Learner: Rereads the same sentence, trying to emulate the coach's fluency.

This practice explicitly connects the decoding skills from the manual to the ultimate purpose of reading: making meaning from text.

‍

Evidence and Limitations: What Does the Research Say?

The evidence base for structured, systematic phonics interventions is strong. However, it's important to look at the specific evidence for Toe by Toe and understand its limitations.

‍

Strengths

A major UK review of literacy interventions found that when delivered meticulously one-to-one, Toe by Toe can yield a "useful" impact. The study reported an average reading accuracy ratio gain of 2.5 (meaning the learner made 2.5 months of progress for every month of intervention) and a reading comprehension ratio gain of 2.0 (Lavan & Talcott, 2020).

Phase	Action	Done?
1. Selection	Identify learners: Use reading assessments to find learners whose primary barrier is decoding, not comprehension.	☐
	Gain staff buy-in: Explain the methodology and, crucially, the time commitment to SLT and TAs.	☐
	Purchase manuals: Ensure one manual per learner-coach pair.	☐
2. Logistics	Assign coaches: Pair each learner with a consistent coach (TA, volunteer, mentor).	☐
	Create a timetable: Ring-fence a daily 20-minute slot for each pair. This is the hardest part. Be realistic.	☐
	Find a quiet space: The intervention needs a distraction-free environment.	☐
3. Training	Brief the coaches: Hold a short session to walk through the manual's instructions. Emphasise the 'three tick' system and the importance of not skipping pages.	☐
	Explain the "why": Ensure coaches understand the purpose of non-words and daily repetition.	☐
	Mandate paired reading: Train coaches to follow every Toe by Toe session with 5-10 minutes of guided oral reading from a separate, level-appropriate book.	☐
4. Monitoring	Initial assessment: Record the learner's reading age or decoding score before starting.	☐
	Regular check-ins: Briefly meet with coaches weekly to discuss progress and challenges.	☐
	Re-assess: Measure progress against the baseline every 10-12 weeks. Look for gains in decoding, fluency, and reading age.	☐
	Review and adapt: If progress is slow, check the fidelity of implementation (is it happening daily? is the coach following the script?). If decoding is secure, plan for graduation from the programme.	☐

‍

A recent Irish study evaluated the programme when delivered by parents at home. It showed large improvements in word identification (a ratio gain of 3.61) and reading fluency (2.40) (O’Rourke, Olsthoorn, and O’Halloran, 2021). This highlights that the intervention can be delivered effectively by non-professionals when the structure is followed.

‍

Limitations

The same Irish study found a minimal impact on reading comprehension (a ratio gain of just 0.9) when Toe by Toe was used without a paired reading component (O’Rourke, Olsthoorn, and O’Halloran, 2021). This is the strongest evidence for the critique that the manual, on its own, does not sufficiently develop comprehension skills. It is a decoding tool, and must be treated as such.

The other major limitation is practical. The requirement for daily, one-to-one delivery is resource-intensive. Research in UK schools has noted that this can lead to "exhaustion and stress for the teacher" and is often compromised by a "lack of resources, time, and money" (Jeffes, 2015). In reality, many schools struggle to deliver more than two or three sessions a week, which can dilute the programme's effectiveness.

‍

Teacher/SENCO Implementation Checklist

For a SENCO or literacy lead considering implementing Toe by Toe:

‍

‍

‍

‍

‍

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What age range is the Toe by Toe manual suitable for? The manual is suitable for learners from around age 7 up to adulthood. The content is age-neutral, focusing purely on the mechanics of reading, so it can be used without embarrassment by older learners who have gaps in their early reading education.

Do teachers or parents need specialist training to deliver it? No. This is one of the most common misconceptions. The manual is explicitly designed to be used by any literate person. All the instructions for the coach are contained in 'coaching boxes' on each page. The key to success is following the highly-structured programme meticulously, not having a prior qualification in teaching reading.

How quickly can you expect to see a measurable improvement in reading age? This varies significantly depending on the learner's starting point and the fidelity of the implementation. With daily 20-minute sessions, many learners show a noticeable increase in confidence and decoding ability within a few weeks. The authors suggest that completing the entire manual, which can take between six and nine months, can often result in a significant jump in reading age. Progress should be monitored regularly to ensure the intervention is working.

---

This week, identify one learner in your class or group who consistently guesses words from pictures or initial letters. In a quiet moment, ask them to read a short list of five simple, phonetically regular non-words (e.g., bim, lup, zot, fev, hic). Their ability to tackle this task will tell you a great deal about whether their difficulty lies with decoding, and if a structured intervention like Toe by Toe might be the right next step.